By KEVIN WALSH and DAVID S. ALLEE
One by one, the venerable institutions of old Coney Island are vanishing. Ruby’s, the last of the boardwalk-facing bars, has served its final drink; Shoot the Freak, one of the most popular game booths, won’t reopen in the spring. And this week, demolition began on the Shore Hotel, pictured below. It’s all part of a development plan to replace the area’s old (and historic) buildings with retail stores and entertainment facilities. In addition to the Shore, destruction is imminent for a number of other structures, as local preservationists have run out of options in court. Below are some sights that will soon be just memories.
The New York Public Library, left; Charles Denson Archive, right
THE SHORE HOTEL
1228 Surf Avenue
The blocks around the Stillwell Avenue subway stop were once lined with hotels and rooming houses. Most are gone, but evidence of them remains: faded signs for the Terminal and the Surf mark the places where vacationers and, later, derelicts and prostitutes once laid their heads. The most visible relic is the Shore Hotel, a three-story brick building constructed in 1903 (in the middle photo above, it’s the boarded-up building in the middle of the block). The ground floor has been home, over the years, to a restaurant, a frozen-custard stand, a beer garden and, in its last iteration, a fried-chicken joint. When I first noticed it in the 1990s, it was the sort of grungy hotel that invited you to imagine what went on inside. I’d see curtains rustling in a window, or people coming in and out, and wonder what brought them to a place like this. I never got the chance to find out: the place was closed in 2007. On Thursday a wrecking crew completed the demolition of its top floor; the rest of the building will fall in the coming weeks.
HENDERSON’S DANCE HALL
1230 Surf Avenue
In the 1970s I spent hours on the pinball machines at Faber’s Fascination, situated in the storefront of this formerly grand music hall. Harpo Marx made his stage debut here in the 1920s. The music hall closed long ago, but Faber’s, one of Coney Island’s few year-round businesses, shuttered in September. Until just a few months ago, Faber’s incandescent sign shone every night, and you can still see the faint outline of where it used to be. Henderson’s was built with impressive facades on both Surf and Stillwell Avenues in 1899, but its west end was shaved back to make way for the widening of Stillwell in the 1920s. Until 1984 the building was home to another boardwalk beauty, Lillie Santangelo’s World in Wax Musee.
1104 Surf Avenue
According to Charles Denson, a Coney Island historian, this plain maroon building is the oldest on Surf Avenue, erected at the corner of Jones Walk in the 1880s by Henry Grashorn as a hardware store. The shop did a brisk business, as the neighborhood’s amusement rides were always in need of repair. Grashorn, in his day, was a neighborhood bigwig and the director of the Bank of Coney Island. He was also the founder and longtime president of the Coney Island Mardi Gras Society, which held an annual parade from 1903 to 1954 (today’s Mermaid Parade is a direct descendant). Of the building’s original features, only the mansard roof remains; its shingles, clapboard siding and dormer windows were removed in the 1980s.
Kevin Walsh runs the blog Forgotten New York and is the author of “Forgotten New York: Views of a Lost Metropolis.” David S. Allee is a photographer.
Old Coney Is
Pinball Buzz is a North American manufacturing company producing fresh and unique Pinball machines, as well as a series of Pinball related regalia. Using all original artwork and created to the highest standards, our machines spark the same joy we found as gamers when we rolled our first quarter into that coin slot so many years ago. Stemming from a lifelong passion, Pinball Buzz is created by gamers, for gamers. We strive to bring high quality, innovative, and captivating experiences for all to enjoy.
Visit our website at pinballadventures.com.
pinhead, pinball, pinball-playing addict, backbox, Pinball Machine, BIFF, flipper, panic flip, Lazarus ball, Nudging, machine, ball, pinball video games, nudge, shake, bumpers, thumper, jet, pop, kick-out hole, ,gobble hole, drain, Ability, Achievement, Action, Arcade, Arrangement, Art, Artist, Artwork, Attempt, American Pinball, Chicago Gaming Company. Dutch Pinball, Haggis Pinball. HomePin. Jersey Jack Pinball. Multimorphic Inc. Penny K Pinball. Quetzal Pinball, Pinball Avdentures, Punny Factory, Ninja Mania, Sushi Mania, That’s Wack, Canada, Vancouver , Spooky Pinball, Stern Pinball, SunCoast Pinball, Team Pinball, Allied Leisure, Alvin G, Atari, Bally Manufacturing, Bill Port, Capcom, Centro Matic, Coffee-Mat, Chicago Coin, Data East, Exhibit Supply Company, Fascination Int., Inc, Game Plan, Genco, Gottlieb, Hankin, Heighway Pinball, Inder, InterFlip/Recreativos Franco, Jennings & Company, Jeutel pinball, Nordamatic, Nuova Bell/Bell Games, Maresa, Mirco Games, Midway Games, Pinstar, Mr. Game, Peyper, Playmatic, Rally Play, Recel/Petaco, Sega Pinball, Sega, S.A. SONIC, Spinball, Taito, Tecnoplay, The Valley Company, Viza, Wico, Williams Electronics / WMS Industries, Zaccaria, Zidware, Back-glass, Ball, Ban, Bells, Bing, Bonus, Brand name, Bumper, Business, Buyer, Cabinet, Challenge, Chicago, Circuit, Coin-operated, Colorful, Company, Competition, Compression, Computer, Concept, Configuration, Control, Coordination, Cost, Count, Craze, Creativity, Culture, Damage, Degree, Design, Development, Dexterity, Digits, Direction, Display, Elaborate, Electric, Electronic, Elimination, Entertainment, Enthusiastic, Era, Execute, Eye-catching, Fancy, Features, Field, Flipper, Forward, Friends,Gamble, Game, Game play, Gate, Gottlieb, Graphics, High score, Highlight, Hit, Hit, Hobby, IFPA, International Flipper Pinball Association, Improve, Incline, Industry, Innovation, Interest, Jackpot, Jostle, Joy, Junior, Kicker, Knob, Knocked down, Launch, Layout, Leg leveler, Legitimate, Levels, License, Lights, Logo, Lose, Loss, Machine, Manipulation, Manufacture, Marketing, Mechanical, Mesmerize, Metal balls, Midway, Modern, Multi-level, Noise, Nudge, Objective, Operate, Opportunities, Pachinko, Pads, PAPA Professional and Amateur Pinball Association, Passion, Pastime, Pins, Planar, Plastic, Play field, Player, Plumb, Plunger, Plunger, Points, Practice, Profit, Progress, Propel, Quality, Quest, Quick, Rack up, Ramp, Relay, Reset, Revenue, Ricochet, Rings, Rounds, Rubber, Sales, Score, Seller, Senior, Sensitivity, Sensor, Shoot, Shoot, Shot, Skillful, Slingshot, Slug, Small, Solenoid, Sound, Speed, Spin, Stopper, Stressful, Strike, Style, Sum, Surface, Switch, Table, Talent, Target, Technique, Tilt, Tilt, Time, Transistor, Translite, Trapping, Trigger, Trigger, Type, Unique, Unpredictability, Value, Video, Visible, Williams, Win, Winner, Wiring, Wizard, Wonder, Worthwhile, Yell, Youth, Zeal, Zero, billiards, pinball game, arcade, pachinko, foosball, videogame, minigolf, slot machine, jukebox, gamers, amusement arcade, miniature golf, joystick, retro, pinball machine, Tetris, snooker, pool hall, arcade